Category Archives: plato

An Introduction to the Politics of Philosophy, Part Final: On Plato’s Crito, The Personification of the Laws, 50a onward

Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 50a-b: Socrates tells Crito to suppose the “Laws and communal interest of Athens” were to confront him, and ask him whether he would deny that he is injuring the Laws and the City if he attempted to escape.

An Introduction to the Politics of Philosophy, Part 5: On Plato’s Crito, 47a-50a

So far in this commentary we have covered the opening of the Crito and all of Crito’s arguments for why Socrates’ choosing to face execution is “unjust.” We are now in the midst of Socrates’ investigation with Crito into the truth of the matter. I want this commentary to end in the next post I

An Introduction to the Politics of Philosophy, Part 4: On Plato’s Crito, 46b-47a

Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 46b: Socrates begins questioning Crito’s argumentation with a declaration. If Crito’s enthusiasm is right and proper, it is a good thing. If not, the stronger the enthusiasm is, the more of a problem it is. The declaration is

An Introduction to the Politics of Philosophy, Part 3: On Plato’s Crito, 45c-46a

The original text, if you’re interested. Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 10. 45c – 46a: When we left off last, Crito was telling Socrates how cheap and easy it would be to escape, and how he could go someplace where he was protected

An Introduction to the Politics of Philosophy, Part 2: Plato’s Crito, 44c – 45b

See Part 1 for a brief introduction to this guide, and a link to the original text. Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 6. 44c: Crito implores Socrates to escape and not accept death. Socrates’ death would mean Crito loses a friend, but also

An Introduction To The Politics of Philosophy: On Plato’s Crito, 43a-44b

I am not using the Greek, nor am I looking at Plato’s Euthydemus, where Crito is a major figure. The purpose of this series of entries is to make good on obligations, and provide a brief sketch from which the thoughtful reader can explore more on his own. If you want to follow along, the

On the Good: Comment on Aristotle’s Ethics, Bk. 1 Chp. 6

Translations of quoted material below and citations are from/of Joe Sachs’ translation, published by Focus, 2002. The essay is as difficult as it gets and is highly, highly speculative. 1. Background: The Audience of the Ethics Aristotle begins by saying he wants to “examine the universal good and go through the difficulties in the way

A Comment on Plato’s "Lovers"

I’m all over the place preparing for oral exams – I’ve always been one to read like 8 books at once, and not get any done, but I’m exceptionally bad nowadays. The problem on my mind right now is from Plato’s “Lovers.” There, Socrates confronts a man trained in music (our equivalent – liberal arts,

On Polemarchus: Commentary on the Republic of Plato, 331d-336a (part 4)

part 1 | part 2 | part 3 | part 4 Notes on 332d-333c Socrates’ questions about medicine and cooking – where each art gives “benefits” that are both “owed and fitting” – lead Polemarchus to assert, perhaps more exuberantly than he did before, that justice must be an art which gives “benefits and harms

On Polemarchus: Commentary on the Republic of Plato, 331d-336a (part 3)

part 1 | part 2 | part 3 | part 4 I. “It seems that Simonides made a riddle, after the fashion of poets, when he said what the just is. For it looks as if he thought that it is just to give to everyone what is fitting, and to this he gave the