Alfred Brendel, Schubert Piano Sonata in B-flat major D. 960

1. Molto moderato – part 1, part 2 | 2. Andante sostenuto | 3. Scherzo | 4. Allegro, ma non troppo – Presto

If you’re pressed for time, the third movement is shorter than the rest. It is excited, a bit whimsical, and certainly not lacking in depth. The sheer amount of music in the first movement alone has me overwhelmed. That starts reverent, soft but full, and then goes on the harmonic journey to end all journeys – you can read about that more here. It feels like a landscape is being painted in front of you; in order to display a breadth of vision, it seems one’s own vision must be even broader.

The second movement contains an incredible amount of drama. It builds slowly and softly to powerful heights, and Brendel’s dynamics, while always good, feel exceptionally sharp here for this listener. It’s not too hard to take in every note and get a sense of what it is doing in the piece, but that doesn’t mean the piece is simple. It probably means a virtuosic piece of piano literature is being played at an amazing level. The theme opening the fourth movement sounds playful, but actually is part of scheme meant to explore a variety of wondrous colors. It ends the entirety of the piece grandly and triumphantly. With Schubert, I’m always wondering what it means to write exceptionally mature works of music. He seems to force the issue in a way few other composers do.


  1. Hi, Ashok! Thanks to the “cleanse” I gave my Feed Reader, I noticed your post. Classical music is fun for me, even though I can’t hear it well. The idea of “orchestrating” so many instruments to create beautiful sounds is almost transcendent.

    Is B-flat on the gloomy side or the buoyant side? You say the third movement is a bit whimsical, so I’m guessing that scale is lighter.

    I only have a few classical composers on my hard drive – Schubert isn’t one of them.



Leave a Reply to Mitchell Allen Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.